Email marketing is constantly evolving, and in 2025, interactive emails in email marketing will become…
Email list segmentation is key to successful email marketing , as it allows sending personalized and relevant messages to different groups of subscribers. The right segmentation can improve open rates, increase engagement and conversions, while bad segmentation can reduce the effectiveness of campaigns.
6 mistakes in email list segmentation
In this blog post, we’ll cover six of the most common email list segmentation mistakes and how you can avoid or correct them.
Why is email list segmentation important?
Segmentation allows you to divide your subscribers into different groups based on their interests, behavior or demographic characteristics. This approach allows you to tailor the content of emails to suit the specific needs of each group. When you send relevant messages, the recipient is more likely to open them, read them, and respond to a call to action (CTA). In this way, segmentation directly affects the efficiency and success of your email campaigns.
Segmentation based on demographic data only
One common mistake is to rely solely on demographics such as age, gender or location. While this data is useful, it doesn’t tell enough about your subscribers’ needs or interests. That being said, campaigns based only on demographic information can be too generic and ineffective.

How to fix: Combine demographic data with behavioral data, such as purchase history, interactions with your site, or past email campaigns. For example, create segments that include subscribers who opened an email in the last month or who added products to their cart but did not complete a purchase.
Ignoring changes in subscriber interests
The interests and needs of your subscribers may change over time. If you don’t keep track of these changes, your emails may become irrelevant to recipients, which may lead to an increase in unsubscribes or your emails being marked as spam.
How to fix it: Regularly update your segments based on new data. Set up automated processes that adjust segmentation based on user behavior, such as email opening frequency or recent purchase. Use surveys or quizzes to learn more about your subscribers’ interests and update their profiles.
Too much segmentation
Over-segmentation can be just as bad as no segmentation at all. When you have too many small segments, it can be difficult to create relevant content for each group, which can lead to wasted resources and confusion.

How to get it right: Stick to basic but effective segments. For example, group subscribers according to their level of engagement (high engagement, medium engagement, and low engagement). This simple segmentation allows you to create content that meets the needs of larger groups while being sufficiently customized.
Ignoring the buying cycle
Not considering the stage the customer is in the buying cycle can lead to sending the wrong messages at the wrong time. For example, sending sales offers to new subscribers who are not yet familiar with your brand may cause a negative reaction.
How to fix it: Differentiate the stages of the buying cycle and create segments based on that. For example, users who have recently made a purchase may be interested in emails with special offers or add-ons for the purchased product, while potential customers who have just signed up to your list may be interested in educational content or guides.
Underutilizing subscriber engagement
If you’re not using subscriber engagement data (such as open rate and click-through rate), you’re missing an opportunity to tailor your campaigns and better align them with the needs of your audience.
How to fix it: Segment subscribers based on their activity. For example, create segments for those who open emails regularly, those who open occasionally, and those who have not opened an email in the last six months. Customize the strategy for each group, e.g. you can create a special reactivation campaign for inactive subscribers.
Sending emails without considering previous actions
Sending email campaigns without considering the recipient’s past interactions with your brand can result in you sending them content they’re not interested in or have already seen.
How to fix: Use data from past campaigns to shape future campaigns. For example, avoid sending the same offer to users who have already purchased a particular product or who have already participated in your promotion. Personalization based on previous actions can significantly increase the relevance of your emails.
Email list segmentation is key to effective email marketing , but it needs to be implemented properly to avoid these mistakes. Focusing on personalization, regularly updating segments, and leveraging behavioral and engagement data can help you improve the performance of your campaigns.
By applying these tips, you’ll not only increase your open rate and click-through rate, but you’ll also build long-term relationships with your subscribers, which is the key to successful email marketing.
For more news and interesting stories, visit our blog page or follow our Instagram profile.
Made by Nemanja Nedeljković – Senior Account Manager @Digitizer